Captain AmericavsSpider-Man

Standard rules

Peak current canon · Standard gear · No prep · Neutral arena

Peak current canonStandard gearNo prepNeutral arenaKO or incapacitation

Change fightersChange

Verdict locked

Make Your Pick

Choose first. Our matchup-specific verdict and full breakdown unlock immediately.

Spoiler-free matchup brief

What decides this fight?

These ratings frame the pressure points without declaring a winner. Powers, counters, equipment and actual win conditions still decide the editorial call.

Captain America

Clearest edge: Combat

95 to 85 — the largest ratings advantage on this side.

Spider-Man

Clearest edge: Power

70 to 40 — the largest ratings advantage on this side.

Closest battleground

Durability

65 to 65 — the category least separated before matchup-specific counters are applied.

Captain America

Ratings
not the verdict

Spider-Man

Strength

Speed

Intelligence

Durability

Combat

Power

Overall

Ratings describe broad attributes. The verdict also weighs counters, resistances, range, equipment and win conditions.

The deciding call

Why Spider-Man gets the edge

Spider-Man wins in most encounters through superhuman physical advantages. Cap's shield and skill make this closer than most superhuman-vs-human fights, but Peter's stats are simply too superior.

Read the full battle breakdown

Matchup context, every pressure point and the strongest counter-case.

Matchup context

This is the same fundamental matchup as Batman vs. Spider-Man — peak human vs. enhanced superhuman. Cap is physically stronger than Batman (super-soldier serum vs. peak training), but Spider-Man still outclasses him.

Battle factor 01

Peter can lift 10 tons vs. Cap's 1,200 pounds. Spider-sense nullifies Cap's shield throws and tactical surprises. Peter's webbing can immobilize Cap and neutralize his shield.

Battle factor 02

Cap's vibranium shield is a better defensive tool than anything Batman has, and his super-soldier endurance exceeds Batman's. But the fundamental problem is the same: Peter is too strong, too fast, and has too much precognition for a peak-human-plus to overcome consistently.

Strongest case for each side

The case for

Captain America

Cap's shield absorbs all kinetic force and is an offensive weapon Peter must respect. His tactical mind and super-soldier serum make him the best human-tier fighter in Marvel. He's fought Spider-Man in the comics and held his own through skill.

The case for

Spider-Man

Spider-Man is 8x stronger, significantly faster, and has precognition. Web-shooters can immobilize Cap or his shield. Peter is nearly as smart as Tony Stark and can out-think Cap tactically while overpowering him physically.

Editorial breakdown