Sonic's speed advantage is too extreme for spider-sense to compensate for.
Spider-Man's spider-sense is incredible precognition, but it needs to connect to physical ability to be useful. Knowing an attack is coming doesn't help if the attack arrives faster than your body can move.
Sonic approaches lightspeed. Spider-Man can dodge bullets. These are fundamentally different speed tiers. Even with spider-sense providing advance warning, Peter's body simply can't move fast enough to dodge attacks at Sonic's speed.
Peter's intelligence and web-shooters provide tactical options โ webbing traps, environmental control, and creative problem-solving. But against someone who can circle the globe in seconds, these strategies have limited effectiveness.
In base form, this is closer. Super Sonic makes it a complete mismatch.
Sonic's speed exceeds what spider-sense can practically counter. His spinning attack and homing dash provide versatile offense. Super Sonic adds invulnerability and massively amplified speed. The speed gap is the defining factor.
Spider-sense provides advance warning of all attacks. Peter's intelligence could find creative counter-strategies. Web traps might slow Sonic momentarily. Peter's 10-ton strength exceeds Sonic's physical power outside of Super form.
Sonic wins through overwhelming speed advantage. Spider-Man's precognition and intelligence make this more competitive than raw stats suggest, but the speed tier difference is too extreme.
Sonic the Hedgehog also fights
Spider-Man also fights