Captain AmericavsDaredevil

Cap's shield is the deciding factor in most encounters. It blocks everything Daredevil can throw, doubles as a ranged weapon that returns to him, and in close quarters it gives him reach and protection simultaneously. Daredevil's billy clubs are effective weapons but cannot match vibranium.

Daredevil's radar sense partially negates Cap's tactical advantages — Matt can sense the shield's trajectory, detect Steve's movements, and fight effectively regardless of conditions. But Cap's enhanced physiology means he hits harder, moves faster, and can take more punishment than Matt can dish out.