Superman leads 5 stats to 1 · Overall 80 vs 93
The rubber pirate captain who ate the Gomu Gomu no Mi—later revealed to be the mythical Human-Human Fruit, Model: Nika—and turned devil fruit powers into a cartoon playground. In Gear 5, Luffy can reshape reality itself with Looney Tunes logic, turning the ground to rubber and grabbing lightning bolts from the sky with his bare hands. He punched a celestial dragon in the face on national television and would absolutely do it again.
Born Kal-El on the doomed planet Krypton, Superman is the gold standard against which all other heroes are measured. Powered by Earth's yellow sun, he possesses near-limitless strength, heat vision that can cut through dimensions, and speed that rivals the Flash. His only real weakness is a glowing green rock—and even that barely slows him down.